Magicsheet logo

Tuple with Same Product

Medium
12.5%
Updated 8/1/2025

Tuple with Same Product

What is this problem about?

The "Tuple with Same Product coding problem" asks you to find the number of tuples (a,b,c,d)(a, b, c, d) such that ab=cda \cdot b = c \cdot d, where a,b,c,da, b, c, d are distinct elements from a given array. For each such unique pair of products, there are 8 possible permutations of the tuple (e.g., if {2,6}\{2, 6\} and {3,4}\{3, 4\} both product 12, the tuples could be (2,6,3,4),(6,2,3,4),(2,6,4,3)...(2,6,3,4), (6,2,3,4), (2,6,4,3)...).

Why is this asked in interviews?

This "Tuple with Same Product interview question" is popular at companies like Meta and Amazon because it tests your ability to use a hash map to reduce the complexity of a counting problem. It evaluates whether you can recognize that you don't need to check four-element combinations directly. Instead, you can find the frequency of all possible products of pairs.

Algorithmic pattern used

The "Array, Hash Table, Counting interview pattern" is the optimal approach. First, we use a nested loop to calculate the product of every possible pair in the array and store these products in a frequency map (Hash Table). If a product PP appears ff times, it means there are ff pairs that result in PP. The number of ways to choose 2 pairs from ff is given by the combination formula fC2=f(f1)2fC2 = \frac{f \cdot (f-1)}{2}. Since each combination of two pairs yields 8 valid tuples, we add f(f1)4f \cdot (f-1) \cdot 4 to our total count.

Example explanation

Input: [2, 3, 4, 6]

  1. Pairs and products:
    • 23=6, 24=8, 2*6=12
    • 34=12, 36=18
    • 4*6=24
  2. Product frequencies: {6:1, 8:1, 12:2, 18:1, 24:1}
  3. Only product 12 has more than one pair (f=2f=2).
  4. Tuples = 2 * (2-1) / 2 * 8 = 1 * 8 = 8. Final answer: 8.

Common mistakes candidates make

One frequent mistake in the "Tuple with Same Product coding problem" is not correctly accounting for the 8 permutations of each pair set. Another error is attempting a brute-force O(n4)O(n^4) search, which is far too slow for an array of 1000 elements (O(n2)O(n^2) is the target). Some candidates also struggle with the distinctness requirement, though the hash map approach inherently handles this since the input array elements are distinct.

Interview preparation tip

To master the "Array, Hash Table, Counting interview pattern," practice problems where you need to "find pairs with property X." Often, the solution involves processing all pairs once, storing results in a map, and then performing a combinatorial calculation on the frequencies.

Similar Questions